When Israel accomplished development of a $1.1 billion above-and-below-ground fence alongside its 40-mile border with Gaza – outfitted with radar units, cameras, surveillance sensors, and remote-controlled weaponry – it was hailed as an “iron wall.”
It was the last word high-tech foil to Hamas’ efforts to assault, particularly through underground tunnels.
However three years later, simply after dawn on Oct. 7, 2023, Hamas forces launched a shock assault. They used low cost drones to knock out refined cameras and weaponry, “low-tech” tractors to concurrently bulldoze by way of dozens of places alongside the 20-foot-high metal fencing, and cling gliders to sail over it.
Why We Wrote This
A narrative centered on
The Hamas forces that carried out the Oct. 7, 2023, bloodbath penetrated a $1.1 billion, high-tech Israeli barrier on the Gaza border. Israel’s military and Shin Guess safety pressure say they failed by counting on expertise on the expense of human intelligence.
What adopted was the deadliest assault ever on Israeli soil. Border communities and the military base there to guard them had been ravaged, 1,200 folks had been killed, and 251 had been taken hostage.
Final week, the primary Israeli investigations into the catastrophe – one by the military and the opposite by Shin Guess, the interior safety service – had been printed. They discovered each safety arms failed to know that Hamas was succesful, not to mention , in finishing up such a mass, coordinated assault.
Among the many causes for the catastrophic intelligence failure was an overreliance on expertise on the expense of the usually Sisyphean activity of human intelligence gathering and evaluation.
“Expertise may be very tempting – AI, cyber, bugging telephones and communications traces, and penetrating computer systems. It’s an sickness not solely inside Shin Guess and navy intelligence however the Mossad, which additionally depends an excessive amount of on expertise,” says Yossi Melman, an Israeli journalist and creator of “Spies In opposition to Armageddon: Inside Israel’s Secret Wars.” “They fell in love with their devices.”
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, in the meantime, has balked at calls for for a state fee of inquiry into Oct. 7, saying such a probe can be biased towards him. Throughout a Knesset debate final week on such an inquiry, some members of the family whose family members had been killed or taken hostage had been denied entry. The wrenching scenes underscored how fraught the difficulty is.
A number of sources
It’s not simply Israeli intelligence that has been susceptible to expertise bias in its work, however Western safety businesses as nicely, argues Ofer Guterman, senior analysis fellow on the Institute for the Analysis of the Methodology of Intelligence, a middle close to Tel Aviv that serves the Israeli intelligence group.
An axiom of intelligence evaluation has at all times been that to get to the reality of what’s occurring, one should use many sorts of sources. “However when you change into reliant on one supply, your line of sight is narrowed,” says Dr. Guterman.
“For strategic assessments, you want greater than innovation; you want the fundamentals of the craft, which is ‘Know your enemy.’ So if coping with Hamas, it’s best to be taught the historical past of the Palestinian folks, of Hamas, of Islam,” he provides.
And it’s exactly these consultants whose work has been scaled again in intelligence items prior to now 20 years, with analysts more and more counting on synthetic intelligence translations for among the info collected. The pondering, consultants say, was that expertise might change a few of these positions.
Miri Eisin, a retired colonel from the military intelligence corps, says instruments like AI translation don’t convey tone, context, or the emotion of an individual whose dialog is being listened to. Rebuilding that capability is now going to be a long-term venture, she says.
“It’s very simple to fireside folks, however as soon as these positions are canceled you lose functionality, and it takes time to construct it once more,” she notes.
“AI may help type by way of info and translate it, however tech ought to be used as a wingman, a helper,” provides Dr. Guterman. “You can not neglect the human expertise. [It’s] such a primary lesson we have to be taught, to by no means once more neglect.”
In 2022, a noncommissioned feminine officer, referred to in Israeli media studies as V, warned her navy intelligence unit that Hamas had plans to execute a broad assault on southern Israel.
However her evaluation was dismissed. It didn’t mesh with the evaluation made at greater ranges that Hamas had been placated, partially by the tens of millions of {dollars} a month it was receiving from Qatar, reportedly with Mr. Netanyahu’s encouragement.
Wanted: extra “black sheep”
Writing within the Israeli each day Yediot Ahronot, an Israeli navy intelligence veteran utilizing the pen title Yariv Inbar mentioned Officer V’s instance was considered one of braveness within the face of intelligence group “groupthink.”
“If a couple of extra daring ‘black sheep’ like V – people who dedicate time to deeply finding out Arab and Islamic tradition and refuse to succumb to groupthink – had challenged the shepherd who strives for herd cohesion, the outcomes might need been completely different,” he wrote.
In a sharply worded indictment, he famous that one of many military probe’s conclusions was the lack of awareness of radical Islamic tradition.
“This can be a troublesome subject to deal with briefly, however the majority of these engaged in intelligence evaluation merely don’t really know or perceive the enemy – neither the Arab adversary nor the Iranian one,” he wrote. “It’s apparent that extra people proficient within the enemy’s language, faith, and tradition are wanted.”
Additionally dismissed had been warnings of irregular Hamas exercise by a unit of feminine “spotter” troopers alongside the Gaza border. It reported seeing militants driving vans, vans, and bikes close to the fence, and reported they seemed to be coaching for a cross-border assault.
Fifteen of the spotters had been amongst greater than 50 troopers killed at their base on Oct. 7. Seven others had been taken hostage. One was killed, one other was rescued, and 5 returned after spending virtually 500 days in captivity.
Inside the intelligence group, info obtained by way of expertise tends to be thought-about extra worthwhile, says reserves Colonel Eisin. However, she cautions, “If you end up trying on the info with incorrect lenses, the expertise isn’t going to assist.”
Lack of brokers
One of many essential causes the Shin Guess didn’t join the dots earlier than Oct. 7 was the problem in recruiting brokers and intelligence sources on the bottom in Gaza, says Mr. Melman, the creator.
Within the West Financial institution, Israel retains navy management and has a broad intelligence community. However Israel withdrew from Gaza 20 years in the past, and inside two years Hamas took energy, ousting the extra reasonable, secular Palestinian Authority. This made Israel’s human intelligence entry reliant on Palestinians who entered Israel to work or obtain medical remedy, for instance.
“So they didn’t have sufficient sources and never sufficient high quality ones,” says Mr. Melman, noting additionally that the state failed to acknowledge that Hamas’ Gaza was by then an unbiased semistate entity with a military at Israel’s border, not merely a terror group attempting to launch occasional pinpoint assaults.
Right here once more the promise of expertise was seen as a panacea.
“On the one hand it makes life simpler: You’ll be able to recruit an agent you don’t have to fulfill, they usually may even be recruited through social media,” Mr. Melman says. “However on the opposite, you lack what human contact provides.”
